Okay, so I’ve got to be straight with you—I’ve been battling chapped lips for basically my entire adult life (thanks, winter). Sometimes it feels like I’ve tried just about every product on the shelves. But you know that one? The yellow tub or tube, Carmex, with its super recognizable logo? That’s the one I finally gave a try after my cousin kept pestering me about it.
Now, first things first, the scent. Oh boy. It’s one of those love-it-or-hate-it situations. For me, that menthol-y kick kinda reminds me of my grandma’s old remedy drawer. Not everyone’s cup of tea, but I weirdly find it comforting? Anyway—if you’re ultra-sensitive to smells, brace yourself.
Texture-wise, Carmex isn’t what I’d call fancy. It’s simple, maybe even a little sticky compared to the glossier stuff out there. But I slapped it on before bed with absolutely zero expectations (honestly thought it’d just be another tube that gets lost in the couch cushions). You know what? I woke up, and my lips actually felt soft. Not a miracle, not a complete cure overnight—but the flaky bits were way less angry.

A week in, and I’ll admit: I keep reaching for the little pot before I go outside, especially if it’s windy. My lips seem a bit less desperate. It’s wild, because I was always firmly Team Fancy Lip Balm, but this goofy old-school Carmex actually works, at least for me. Some folks say it makes their lips even drier, though, which is confusing—maybe it depends on your skin or how often you use it? (I’d say once or twice a day max, or it starts to feel too much.)
Is it a total game-changer? Hard to say. I mean—it doesn’t taste great if you accidentally lick your lips (ugh), and the tingling is strong. But honestly, for the price, it’s way better than a lot of the new, over-hyped stuff I’ve tried.
So, are my lips cured forever? Hah, I wish. But for now, Carmex sits in my jacket pocket and gets used pretty much every day. If your lips are a mess like mine, especially in the cold months, it might be worth giving Carmex a shot—even if it’s just to see what all the fuss is about (and you might wind up like me, unexpectedly attached).